The Oregon Faith Report - Faith News from Oregon

A faith response to Mel Gibson meltdown

July 27, 2010

By Randy Alcorn
Eternal Perspectives Ministries
Sandy, Oregon

With the recent allegations against actor Mel Gibson, there’s been a number of responses to his situation that cry out for an eternal perspective. (When Gibson released his movie The Passion of the Christ in 2004, I wrote a review of the movie for our quarterly newsletter, and a follow-up response based on some of the things I said in my first article about Gibson. In both articles, I wrote, “Pray for him, absolutely, selectively agree with and support him, yes, but don’t make him—or anyone else—Christianity’s poster boy or spokesperson…Every time Christians get mesmerized by and try to capitalize on fame and celebrity, it ends up hurting them, biting us and undermines rather than elevates our Lord.”)

Although these following principles about image and character are pulled from an article I wrote years ago about O.J. Simpson, they still prove just as true today as they did then.

The difference between image and character. Image is what you are on a football field, in a movie, and in Hertz commercials. Character is what you are in the dark, when no one but God is looking. What are the traits it takes to get and stay famous? In many cases the answer includes a mammoth ego, self-absorption, and an impassioned craving for public approval. These very traits that compel one to pursue fame both reflect and produce a private inner life lacking in substance and integrity.

Anyone can look good in front of an audience, or even in front of their friends. It’s an entirely different thing to stand naked before God, to be known as you truly are on the inside. “Do not consider his appearance or his height . . . The Lord does not look at the things man looks at. man looks at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart” (1 Samuel 16:7).

The difference between a hero and a celebrity. Fame is one thing. Virtue is another. The two aren’t even remotely related. In fact, the more famous you become the harder it is to cultivate and retain virtue. Being a hero is something entirely different than being a celebrity. Celebrities are just people with good looks, talent, money, and the ability to draw attention to themselves. Heroes are people who stand courageously for what is right, often against the tide of public opinion, and at great cost to themselves.

Many public figures have proven long on image and short on character, just as many faithful servants of God have been short on image and long on character. Politicians are celebrities. But if they steal from the country, cheat on their wives, and promote the ruthless killing of unborn children, no one in their right mind can consider them heroes. (That many do so simply demonstrates our society is not in its right mind.)

When you and I stand before God and give an account of our lives, the ability to run with a football or manage a company or write a newsletter article will mean nothing. Our dependence on Christ to cleanse us of our sins and empower us to a new way of living will mean everything.

The difference between a self-made man and a God-made man. We value a man who is independent. God values a man who is dependent on Him. We value a man who marches to his own beat. God values a man who marches to His beat. We value a man who is his own authority, who makes up the rules as he goes. God values a man who submits, who follows those unbending ancient rules made by Another. We value a man who believes in himself, who makes himself great. God values a man who believes in Him, recognizing He alone is truly great.

The difference between high self-esteem and accurate self-esteem. People often say, “I can’t believe that [insert name of a person in the news] is capable of such evil.” Of course he is. So are you. So am I. We’ve fallen for the old lie, propagated by secular humanism and modern psychology, that man is basically good. But we’re terribly arrogant and naive to believe this. Read Romans 1-3 and see what God says about the human condition. Look at human history. Look around you. We’re all capable of horrendous evil. The man who thinks he is incapable of adultery and crimes of hatred and passion is not on guard against them, and does not call upon Christ to save him from them.

Years ago I read a fascinating and chilling book by Robert Lifton, The Nazi Doctors. As a psychologist interviewing former Nazi doctors and their surviving victims, he hoped to discover what made these “monsters” tick. What he discovered was much more frightening—the fact that these were in fact quite ordinary men who, given the opportunity, did horribly evil things. As long as we consider the Nazis monsters, we can separate ourselves from them. It’s only when we realize that we ourselves are of the same stock that we can come to terms with our capacity for evil and our need for Jesus.

The difference between Hollywood values and values that really matter. Years ago, on the day after Simpson’s “chase” on the L. A. freeways, I was attending Promise Keepers in Portland, with nearly 30,000 other men. (Another 5,000 were turned away—there just wasn’t room.) Here, like the quarter of a million other men attending Promise Keepers gatherings that year, were men gathered to uplift the very values and power for righteous living that O. J. Simpson so desperately lacked. Men were learning about God, about taking responsibility, about loving and serving their wives and children.

The event went by in Portland largely unnoticed by television news that night. All those men at civic stadium did was commit themselves to being faithful in their homes and churches and communities and society, to keeping sacred promises in the daily grind of life. These men wanted to cumulatively build a track record of faithfulness to God and family. They wished to become heroes, if to no one else, to their own children. Small acts of daily faithfulness don’t make the news. But they matter much more than what does.

Commitments like the ones those men made that night will give our children, our churches, and our society an example to follow unmatched by that of any celebrity. A life enthusiastically applauded in the final day by the only audience that ultimately matters . . . the Audience of One.

Randy Alcorn

Print This Post Print This Post    Email This Post Email This Post

Discuss this article

virtuous July 27, 2010

Randy, this article caught my eye, because I have so enjoyed your novels. Safely Home particularly built my faith and opened my eyes to the invisible Church.
Re: Gibson, I also believe the “works” mentality is so ingrained in him, that he honestly believes that building a chapel or making a movie about Jesus will somehow be weighed in God’s balances, outweighing his sins. I have not listened to the actual recordings of his telephone rants, nor do I care to, but the transcribed snippets in the media are frightening and certainly do not reflect one who is controlled by the Holy Spirit. Yes, I believe even a godly man can fall badly and then repent. I just pray that Gibson turns to the true God, and finds His truth in His Word. The people who are enjoying and profiting from his downfall probably have no right to cast stones themselves. It is just that Gibson’s words are being shouted from the rooftops.

David July 27, 2010

I hope you will not waste your entire life believing in a sky-fairy. Life is short, so have fun without some eternal damnation hanging over your head.

Looking Through You August 15, 2010

What I took away from this is that the author has a holier than thou narcissism equal or great to the large groups of people the author unfairly categorizes and condemns.


“in many cases” is just not true. It’s the few that make the headlines. This is just pure nonsense.

First, there is no causal link between subtance and integrity and fame or even large egos. Many people with large egos do many good, selfless things.

Many people are famous BECAUSE of their good deeds– Mother Theresa, countless charity workers ‘famous’ in their own communities.

Others use their fame to do good works: Paul Newman, Jimmy Carter, and yes, even Al Gore, for example.

You use Gibson as an example. Gibson is an alcoholic. Everyone knows that. Not everyone knows that alcoholism is more than just a physical disease, but it’s a personality, too. They tend to be massively insecure but hide it with the impression of a big ego. Once they conquer the disease, their personalities usually change. Yet ignorant you subtly condemning him here, implies he lacks substance, without knowing ALL of him, the way God does. Shame, shame, shame on judgmental you.

You condemn politicians as a group for the sins of a few. You could do the same with many ministers and church people who have defrauded their flocks (embezzlement happens almost every day at some church somewhere–and that’s just the tip of the iceberg of what evil things church officials have done. Let’s not forget the pedophilia rampant in the Catholic Church.)

Condemning our elected officials, the majority of whom are hard-working, church-going family people is just evil on so many levels. Such remarks spreads apathy and decreases civic engagement, which crumbles democracy. You ARE the problem you complain about.

Even condemning actors as a whole is just nonsensical and evil. Most feild called to their profession the way the rest of us do. Many avoid the limelight, but are compelled, usually by contract, to do a certain amoutn of PR. The extremely Johnny Depp comes to mind. Paul Newman.

You used Gibson’s personal problems to bring attention to yourself, telling us things we already know.
You talk about how God sees us. Why not just shut up about Gibson, politicians and others and just let God deal with them? Stop judging others lest you be judged even more unfavorably.

And while you are at it, could you please learn to properly use Subject, verb and predicate, especially in topic sentences of paragraphs? this article would not pass an 8th grade writing test.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please answer the following question to confirm that you are a real person: *


Subscribe to Weekly Updates

Oregon Religion News Ticker

Top Business News


Top Natural Resource News


Top Faith News


Copyright © 2019, OregonReport. All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Use - Copyright - Legal Policy | Contact Oregon Report